Providence Journal - Subscribe Now & Get Our Latest Offer

Politics

With rare haste, new magistrate is sworn in

Comments  | Recommend
March 6, 2009 12:40 pm
By Katherine Gregg

PROVIDENCE, RI -- With an alacrity rarely seen in state government, a top aide to House Speaker William J. Murphy was sworn into his new job as a $147,947 a year magistrate Thursday night, only a week after his nomination and an hour after the state Senate confirmed him on a vote that was not even posted on its Web site in advance.

Court spokesman Craig Berke today confirmed that the Superior Court's newest magistrate, Patrick T. Burke, was sworn in by the court's presiding justice, Joseph F. Rodgers Jr., last night at the Licht Judicial Complex. "He starts Monday,'' Berke said.

Burke, 45, will be moving into an opening created by Joseph A. Keough's retirement in December, though in actuality he will take over the position magistrate and former Rep. William McAtee has held for more than 15 years, overseeing the pre-arraignment calendar, while McAtee steps into Keough's position.

Unlike judges, magistrates are not vetted by the state's Judicial Nominating Commission in an open and competitive arena. They are recommended by the top judges of each court, in this case, Rodgers, who urged speedy action on his Feb. 26 nomination of Burke because illness and retirements have left his court "four judicial officers short."

Asked why the Senate did not provide advance notice of Thursday night's vote on its calendar, Senate President M. Teresa Paiva Weed, a lawyer, said the "desk was closed" when the Senate Judiciary Committee approved Burke's nomination Tuesday. She provided no further explanation for taking the nomination up on "immediate consideration."

A graduate of the Creighton University School of Law and former public defender, Burke was at the center of a controversial court case that worked its way to the state Supreme Court in the 1990s that evolved from his arrest by the Warwick police in 1993 after they observed his car weaving on Route 2 around 2:30 a.m.

The police charged him with refusing to submit to a portion of the breath test, and the traffic court suspended his license and scheduled a hearing. But the hearing never took place after being continued seven times, the last time at the prosecutor's request because she knew Burke through the courts and questioned whether she could be impartial.

Burke's lawyer, then House Speaker John B. Harwood, filed for dismissal in 1996, saying the state's action deprived Burke of his right to a speedy trial. Judge John F. Lallo dismissed the charge, but fined Burke for a roadway violation.

The attorney general's office appealed to a three-judge traffic appeals court panel, which upheld the dismissal. The attorney general appealed to the state Supreme Court, which refused to hear the case.

In the moments before yesterday's vote, Sen. Charles J. Levesque, D-Portsmouth, cited the ability "to recognize that there are bad people and you have to prosecute them for the good of all, but there are also very good people who have had bad days and you have to recognize the difference. Pat Burke is somebody who recognizes the difference. "

Share Your Thoughts
Guidelines: We welcome your thoughts, but for the sake of all readers, please refrain from the use of obscenities, personal attacks or racial slurs. All comments are subject to our terms of service and may be removed. Repeat offenders may lose commenting privileges.
Providence Journal - Subscribe Now & Get Our Latest Offer
MOST COMMENTED